Although I love the idea of peer-review, I haven't always had ideal experiences with the exercise in the past. However, I can honestly say that I enjoyed reading my classmates papers and having them read mine over the course of two classes.
The first day of peer-review, I read two papers (by Anna and Adam) that exposed me to entirely different topics: humor and existentialism! I admired their unique approach to their papers and enjoyed reading them. Both Anna and Adam took an outside concept--both very challenging and broad ones, at that--and applied them specifically and skillfully to Buffy the Vampire Slayer.
The second day of peer-review, I had the pleasure of reading a different batch of papers. What stood out most to me about the second session was the unexpected similarity of my paper and Adam Otto's. Honestly, I was nervous about Adam reading my paper about Willow Rosenberg since he has vocalized and blogged about his distaste for Willow. My paper stemmed from the idea of Willow being impossible to write off and how she deserves careful consideration. I was pleased to read Adam's paper about Cordelia Chase in which he essentially embraces the same premise--there is more to Cordelia than meets the eye and she also deserves thoughtful examination.
From the beginning, our class has been a huge mixture of opinions, voices, and approaches. The papers have been a great culmination of that mixture. Thanks to everyone who read my paper and gave me helpful feedback; I really appreciate it!
Also, I'll just say that I absolutely loved this class--perfectly organized, consistent/fair workload, and oh yeah--FUN. I've noted progress in my own writing, and that feels pretty darn good. So, Dr. H, thank you!
Best wishes to everyone with your papers. I can't wait for the presentations. :)
2 comments:
You're very welcome, Hannah! I loved reading your Willow paper :) Thank you for my feedback as well.
I completely agree with you about the writing progression and the overall course. The course was pretty much perfect in m opinion. We've all had the chance to voice our opinions--both good and bad, and had the chance to talk everything out. I've also noticed a difference my writing too.
I had the same issue with peer review in the past. This class has a bunch of bright individuals and capable writers though, and it made this peer review session a rewarding one. I've learned alot from this course, and it has definitely improved my writing skills.
Post a Comment