Sunday, January 30, 2011

Uncanny Valley and "Hush"

Can't even shout, can't even cry
The Gentlemen are coming by
Looking in windows, knocking on doors
They need to take seven and they might take yours
Can't call to mom, can't say a word
You're gonna die screaming but you won't be heard.


This rhyme sets the stage and mood for “Hush,” one of the most highly regarded episodes of BtVS, and the only one to receive and Emmy nomination. Most of my friends that are involved with the cult of Buffy think of this one as their favorite episodes. The nightmarish creatures that Buffy encounters in this episode, The Gentlemen, bring a level of creepy that the show had not displayed before or after. The reason the basically-human-looking Gentlemen are so disturbing is their closeness to humanity they fall squarely into uncanny valley.

For the uninitiated, uncanny valley is the name of a phenomenon in appearance from the entertainment business. The rule is that the closer something appears to being human, the less relateable and the more disturbing the character's appearance. The reason for this is that we, the audience, pick up on small discrepancies in movement or any number of other things and know that the image is wrong. The Gentlemen, with their rictus grins of metal teeth, pale corpse visages, and silent, miming communication, fall squarely in at the bottom off uncanny valley. 
I don't own the image, and this article about uncanny valley is at http://www.sarahangliss.com/spotted/uncannyvids

3 comments:

awilliams6369 said...

Very Interesting! So I'm guessing that because the gentlemen resemble a human but behave so un-human like is why their image is more frightening? I had never heard of uncanny valley before! Great post!

JoshMeadows said...

Well, they are uncanny because they appear "almost" human, and it is with our knowledge that they are NOT human that creates the effect. The developers of the show, I'm sure, pushed them into human territory with human actors while making them just a BIT off in order to create the mental struggle.

Video games, in particular, are struggling to rise out of the uncanny valley right now. They are not succeeding.

Heidi said...

I love this post--and the comments about it. We should talk about this concept in class!